Showing posts with label proof. Show all posts
Showing posts with label proof. Show all posts

Thursday, August 28, 2008

Are these really parallelograms - answers

These are answers to my earlier post where I asked if certain figures necessarily are parallelograms.

The question was: Does the given information in each diagram guarantee that each is a parallelogram?

Figure 1:
This one you can't get around; it ends up being a parallelogram, actually a dandy rhombus. Let's prove it. You can notice it has lots of sides of the same length. If we draw a diagonal, we get two triangles with all kinds of same sides:

The two triangles ABD and BCD end up having all three sides the same. So by the SSS triangle congruence theorem, they are congruent triangles. Hence, their corresponding angles are the same.

I've marked the corresponding angles with the same colors. Actually the triangles are even isosceles so the blue and purple angles are even congruent... but we don't need that fact.

To prove ABCD is a parallelogram, we need to prove its two sides are parallel. And for that, it's often handy to use the corresponding angle theorem: if corresponding angles are equal, the lines are parallel. So image that we continue the line segment CD. Notice the additional green angle that I've marked:


How do I know it actually is a "green angle" (congruent with the other green angle)? It's because the three angles, being angles of a triangle, add up to 180:
+ + = 180. And the three angles being there along the same line (the continuation of CD), it must be. This sounds a little too complicated as I'm typing it. Perhaps I shouldn't have marked it green. Anyhow, since it IS congruent with the other green angle at C, then the line segments BC and AD must be parallel.

A similar argument would prove the other two sides parallel.

Figure 2: This isn't necessarily a parallelogram, but it IS always a trapezoid:



Figure 3:
This one is trickier, but it isn't necessarily a parallelogram. I used a compass to find a way to make this into a trapezoid:ABCD is a trapezoid with the non-parallel sides 5 units long.

Figure 4: This one is actually a repetition of the Figure 1, because it has the opposites sides of same length. We can use the identical argument to prove it is a parallelogram.

Are these really parallelograms - answers

These are answers to my earlier post where I asked if certain figures necessarily are parallelograms.

The question was: Does the given information in each diagram guarantee that each is a parallelogram?

Figure 1:
This one you can't get around; it ends up being a parallelogram, actually a dandy rhombus. Let's prove it. You can notice it has lots of sides of the same length. If we draw a diagonal, we get two triangles with all kinds of same sides:

The two triangles ABD and BCD end up having all three sides the same. So by the SSS triangle congruence theorem, they are congruent triangles. Hence, their corresponding angles are the same.

I've marked the corresponding angles with the same colors. Actually the triangles are even isosceles so the blue and purple angles are even congruent... but we don't need that fact.

To prove ABCD is a parallelogram, we need to prove its two sides are parallel. And for that, it's often handy to use the corresponding angle theorem: if corresponding angles are equal, the lines are parallel. So image that we continue the line segment CD. Notice the additional green angle that I've marked:


How do I know it actually is a "green angle" (congruent with the other green angle)? It's because the three angles, being angles of a triangle, add up to 180:
+ + = 180. And the three angles being there along the same line (the continuation of CD), it must be. This sounds a little too complicated as I'm typing it. Perhaps I shouldn't have marked it green. Anyhow, since it IS congruent with the other green angle at C, then the line segments BC and AD must be parallel.

A similar argument would prove the other two sides parallel.

Figure 2: This isn't necessarily a parallelogram, but it IS always a trapezoid:



Figure 3:
This one is trickier, but it isn't necessarily a parallelogram. I used a compass to find a way to make this into a trapezoid:ABCD is a trapezoid with the non-parallel sides 5 units long.

Figure 4: This one is actually a repetition of the Figure 1, because it has the opposites sides of same length. We can use the identical argument to prove it is a parallelogram.

Monday, August 18, 2008

Are these really parallelograms?

Continuing with the idea in my post about Squares that aren't squares?, let's look at the following "parallelograms".

The question is the same:

Does the given information in each diagram guarantee that each is a parallelogram?

If you don't think so, your mission is to draw a quadrilateral with the given information but that clearly does NOT look like a parallelogram.

Figure 1:


Figure 2:


Figure 3:


Figure 4:


Again, these problems let students practice logical reasoning, and also learn about parallelograms, of course. See answers here.

Are these really parallelograms?

Continuing with the idea in my post about Squares that aren't squares?, let's look at the following "parallelograms".

The question is the same:

Does the given information in each diagram guarantee that each is a parallelogram?

If you don't think so, your mission is to draw a quadrilateral with the given information but that clearly does NOT look like a parallelogram.

Figure 1:


Figure 2:


Figure 3:


Figure 4:


Again, these problems let students practice logical reasoning, and also learn about parallelograms, of course. See answers here.

Friday, April 25, 2008

High school geometry - a review

It's done! Finally! Took me some time to finish this review, perhaps because it involved three products:
  • The book Geometry: A Guided Inquiry. As the name suggests, this book is based on letting students learn about theorems and their proofs in the setting of "guided inquiries" or interesting problems. It is quite unique in its approach.

  • A Home Study Companion which includes solutions and about 300 interactive demonstrations

  • Geometer's Sketchpad - dynamic geometry software.

This review isn't just what you typically find on the web; someone called it an "exquisite in-depth review". It's fairly long... with sample pages and other pictures, examples, and more.

I encourage you to read it even if you don't need a high school geometry book right now... because you'll get valuable insight just HOW GOOD geometry instruction can be, how the book handles proof, or what to think about an axiomatic vs. discovery based geometry text.

Review of Geometry: A Guided Inquiry with Geometer's Sketchpad and Home Study Companion.

High school geometry - a review

It's done! Finally! Took me some time to finish this review, perhaps because it involved three products:
  • The book Geometry: A Guided Inquiry. As the name suggests, this book is based on letting students learn about theorems and their proofs in the setting of "guided inquiries" or interesting problems. It is quite unique in its approach.

  • A Home Study Companion which includes solutions and about 300 interactive demonstrations

  • Geometer's Sketchpad - dynamic geometry software.

This review isn't just what you typically find on the web; someone called it an "exquisite in-depth review". It's fairly long... with sample pages and other pictures, examples, and more.

I encourage you to read it even if you don't need a high school geometry book right now... because you'll get valuable insight just HOW GOOD geometry instruction can be, how the book handles proof, or what to think about an axiomatic vs. discovery based geometry text.

Review of Geometry: A Guided Inquiry with Geometer's Sketchpad and Home Study Companion.

Thursday, April 3, 2008

Problem solving & math as an art

Continuing on a litlte bit more with my thoughts concerning Lochart's Lament.

Lockhart starts out his lament with a comparison: WHAT IF music teaching only consisted of learning to write music, write notes on paper, and only after high school level would students be allowed to actually hear and make music? WHAT IT art instruction would consist of "paint by numbers" until high school, which is when they'd actually start applying paint...

Lockhart remarks that if he wanted to destroy a child's natural curiosity and love of pattern-making, "...I simply wouldn't have the imagination to come up with the kind of senseless, soul-crushing ideas that constitute contemporary mathematics education."

He calls school mathematics "pseudo-mathematics", where emphasis is on the accurate yet mindless manipulation of symbols.

These are, of course, very strong words. I don't fully agree... I don't feel all that's done at school would be pseudo-mathematics or mindless manipulation of symbols. Really, you CAN teach addition so that it makes sense, and we need to learn the symbols for it (5 + 6 = 11).

Lockhart uses the triangle example that I blogged about before to illustrate how mathematics is an ART:

"To do mathematics is to engage in an act of discovery and conjecture, intuition and inspiration; to be in a state of confusion -- not because it makes no sense to you, but because you gave it sense and you still don't understand what your creation is up to; to have a breakthrough idea; to be frustrated as an artist; to be awed and overwhelmed by an almost painful beauty; to be alive."

I can see where he's coming from... yet I wouldn't put down so harshly all that is done within school mathematics. There IS a place for drills, for computation practice, for studying algorithms, measuring units, and so on.

Lockhart says, "The main problem with school mathematics is that there are no problems." Here I agree. We should add GOOD PROBLEMS - or true problem solving to our lessons. I don't mean "exercises"...

"But a problem, a genuine honest-to-goodness natural human question -- that's another thing.
How long is the diagonal of a cube? Do prime numbers keep going on forever? Is infinity a number? How many ways can I symmetrically tile a surface? The history of mathematics is the history of mankind's engagement with questions like these, not the mindless regurgitation of formulas and algorithms (together with contrived exercises designed to make use of them).

A good problem is something you don't know how to solve. That's what makes it a good puzzle, and a good opportunity. A good problem does not just sit there in isolation, but serves as a springboard to other interesting questions. A triangle takes up half its box. What about a pyramid inside its three-dimensional box? Can we handle this problem in a similar way?
"

In other words, good problems do not simply practice a technique or idea that the student just saw used in an example. Notice: a good problem is such that you don't initially know how to solve it.

Now, this does not mean kids shouldn't solve "routine" problems or exercises, because ONLY by having KNOWLEDGE of techniques and concepts can new, non-routine problems be tackled.

But I'd recommend you take some time, perhaps a day every two weeks, where your math lesson consists of problem solving so that your students CAN experience this kind of problem solving process that leads them to conjecture, to investigate, to THINK hard, fail first but persevere, to justify their thoughts -- to come up with proofs.

It is of course even better if a teacher can lead the teaching with such good questions or problems even more often, such as starting the lesson with an interesting problem that leads to a new concept. But I realize not all of us can do that, and that it may take more time than direct instruction. If you can give them at least a glimpse of it sometimes, feel proud, because then you've done better than many.

... For good problems, check some resources here.

Problem solving & math as an art

Continuing on a litlte bit more with my thoughts concerning Lochart's Lament.

Lockhart starts out his lament with a comparison: WHAT IF music teaching only consisted of learning to write music, write notes on paper, and only after high school level would students be allowed to actually hear and make music? WHAT IT art instruction would consist of "paint by numbers" until high school, which is when they'd actually start applying paint...

Lockhart remarks that if he wanted to destroy a child's natural curiosity and love of pattern-making, "...I simply wouldn't have the imagination to come up with the kind of senseless, soul-crushing ideas that constitute contemporary mathematics education."

He calls school mathematics "pseudo-mathematics", where emphasis is on the accurate yet mindless manipulation of symbols.

These are, of course, very strong words. I don't fully agree... I don't feel all that's done at school would be pseudo-mathematics or mindless manipulation of symbols. Really, you CAN teach addition so that it makes sense, and we need to learn the symbols for it (5 + 6 = 11).

Lockhart uses the triangle example that I blogged about before to illustrate how mathematics is an ART:

"To do mathematics is to engage in an act of discovery and conjecture, intuition and inspiration; to be in a state of confusion -- not because it makes no sense to you, but because you gave it sense and you still don't understand what your creation is up to; to have a breakthrough idea; to be frustrated as an artist; to be awed and overwhelmed by an almost painful beauty; to be alive."

I can see where he's coming from... yet I wouldn't put down so harshly all that is done within school mathematics. There IS a place for drills, for computation practice, for studying algorithms, measuring units, and so on.

Lockhart says, "The main problem with school mathematics is that there are no problems." Here I agree. We should add GOOD PROBLEMS - or true problem solving to our lessons. I don't mean "exercises"...

"But a problem, a genuine honest-to-goodness natural human question -- that's another thing.
How long is the diagonal of a cube? Do prime numbers keep going on forever? Is infinity a number? How many ways can I symmetrically tile a surface? The history of mathematics is the history of mankind's engagement with questions like these, not the mindless regurgitation of formulas and algorithms (together with contrived exercises designed to make use of them).

A good problem is something you don't know how to solve. That's what makes it a good puzzle, and a good opportunity. A good problem does not just sit there in isolation, but serves as a springboard to other interesting questions. A triangle takes up half its box. What about a pyramid inside its three-dimensional box? Can we handle this problem in a similar way?
"

In other words, good problems do not simply practice a technique or idea that the student just saw used in an example. Notice: a good problem is such that you don't initially know how to solve it.

Now, this does not mean kids shouldn't solve "routine" problems or exercises, because ONLY by having KNOWLEDGE of techniques and concepts can new, non-routine problems be tackled.

But I'd recommend you take some time, perhaps a day every two weeks, where your math lesson consists of problem solving so that your students CAN experience this kind of problem solving process that leads them to conjecture, to investigate, to THINK hard, fail first but persevere, to justify their thoughts -- to come up with proofs.

It is of course even better if a teacher can lead the teaching with such good questions or problems even more often, such as starting the lesson with an interesting problem that leads to a new concept. But I realize not all of us can do that, and that it may take more time than direct instruction. If you can give them at least a glimpse of it sometimes, feel proud, because then you've done better than many.

... For good problems, check some resources here.

Wednesday, January 17, 2007

Quite funny: Proof by...

By way of Natural Blogarithms, we can learn some "useful" proof techniques...

For example:

"Proof by vigorous handwaving: Works well in a classroom or seminar setting.

Proof by forward reference: Reference is usually to a forthcoming paper of the author, which is often not as forthcoming as at first.

Proof by funding: How could three different government agencies be wrong?"

There's much more!

Quite funny: Proof by...

By way of Natural Blogarithms, we can learn some "useful" proof techniques...

For example:

"Proof by vigorous handwaving: Works well in a classroom or seminar setting.

Proof by forward reference: Reference is usually to a forthcoming paper of the author, which is often not as forthcoming as at first.

Proof by funding: How could three different government agencies be wrong?"

There's much more!

Thursday, September 28, 2006

Online math resources

Resources

These are some of the links I've added to my site recently. Maybe there's some that interest you.

Mathopenref.com
Free online textbook for high school geometry; not finished.

GapMinder
Visualizing human development trends (such as poverty, health, gaps, income on a global scale) via stunning, interactive statistical graphs. This is an interactive, dynamic tool and not just static graphs. Download the software or the reports for free.

How to write proofs
A 12-part tutorial on proof writing. Includes direct proof, proof by contradiction, proof by contrapositive, mathematical induction, if and only if, and proof strategies.

Money Math
Crystal clear tutorial on interest.

Graph Mole
A fun game about plotting points in coordinate plane. Plot points before the mole eats the vegetables.




All sorts of sites to explore! But if those didn't fit your bill, if you're in need of a game or tutorial about specific math topic, check my link lists of online math resources; they're organized by level and topic:



Math help, Homework help, tutoring

Math history, Problem solving, Hands-on, For Gifted, Mental Math, Test prep

Basic operations, Times tables, Place value

Time, Money, Measuring, Geometry

Fractions, Decimals, Percent, Integers

Measuring, Coordinate Plane, Geometry

Algebra, Graphing, Calculus

Geometry,  Trigonometry, Statistics, Logic

Math games, quizzes, or interactive tutorials websites

Online math resources

Resources

These are some of the links I've added to my site recently. Maybe there's some that interest you.

Mathopenref.com
Free online textbook for high school geometry; not finished.

GapMinder
Visualizing human development trends (such as poverty, health, gaps, income on a global scale) via stunning, interactive statistical graphs. This is an interactive, dynamic tool and not just static graphs. Download the software or the reports for free.

How to write proofs
A 12-part tutorial on proof writing. Includes direct proof, proof by contradiction, proof by contrapositive, mathematical induction, if and only if, and proof strategies.

Money Math
Crystal clear tutorial on interest.

Graph Mole
A fun game about plotting points in coordinate plane. Plot points before the mole eats the vegetables.




All sorts of sites to explore! But if those didn't fit your bill, if you're in need of a game or tutorial about specific math topic, check my link lists of online math resources; they're organized by level and topic:



Math help, Homework help, tutoring

Math history, Problem solving, Hands-on, For Gifted, Mental Math, Test prep

Basic operations, Times tables, Place value

Time, Money, Measuring, Geometry

Fractions, Decimals, Percent, Integers

Measuring, Coordinate Plane, Geometry

Algebra, Graphing, Calculus

Geometry,  Trigonometry, Statistics, Logic

Math games, quizzes, or interactive tutorials websites

Friday, June 16, 2006

Enjoying geometry proofs

Here recently I finished reading the two Dr. Math geometry books. (I will be writing a review of them, and I can say they're pretty good & inexpensive books!)

The one meant for high school geometry had as its last chapter circles and theorems about circles. Well circles never were the strongest part of my mathematical knowledge, for whatever reason... (I think it stems from the fact that so big part of school geometry concentrates on calculating areas and volumes, and not on properties of figures.)

So I wanted to brush up on circle theorems. I quickly read over the circle chapter on another geometry book I have, called "Geometry: A Guided Inquiry". (I can recommend that book as well. It often asks the student to explore and try find theorems. See more info here.)

I don't know about you, but to me, reading & learning theorems and proofs can be enjoyable. First you maybe struggle to grasp it all, but afterwards there is a great satisfying feeling and admiration of the logical process - and it's BEAUTIFUL.

So I thought I'd blog about inscribed angles... so you see a tiny glimpse of this logical process of proof.

1) Let's suppose we've already proved this theorem: that inscribed angles are equal, and are half of the corresponding central angle.



All these angles A are equal (or congruent as they say), and are half of angle B.

I can even draw many of them in the same pic: now the red, blue, black, and green angles have the same measure, exactly half of angle B.




(As a sideline, if we make B to be 180 degrees so it forms a diameter, then what is the measure of A?)

For proof of this theorem, see Inscribed and Central Angles in a Circle: What is this about? A Mathematical Droodle - a nice interactive applet shows the angle relationship, too.

2) THEN, after understanding that, let's consider two chords in a circle that intersect.




Filling in some more lines, we get what I'd call the "slanted timeglass figure".

We see there are two inscribed angles here, from the same points, and they're congruent (angles A and A').

Angles B and B' are congruent since they're vertical angles.

SO.... even the third angles of these two triangles must be equal (since angles in a triangle always add up to 180 degrees).

It follows that we have two SIMILAR TRIANGLES! We have just PROVEN that the time glass figure inside a circle consists of two similar (same shape) triangles.




Well that was just a tiny tiny glimpse, but I hope you see how this process could work. And I wish our students can get these tiny glimpses even BEFORE high school geometry - to learn appreciate math a little more, to see its beauty in action, to learn what proving is all about. In my mind, proofs are NOT something boring - they're part of the beauty of mathematics.


Tags: ,

Enjoying geometry proofs

Here recently I finished reading the two Dr. Math geometry books. (I will be writing a review of them, and I can say they're pretty good & inexpensive books!)

The one meant for high school geometry had as its last chapter circles and theorems about circles. Well circles never were the strongest part of my mathematical knowledge, for whatever reason... (I think it stems from the fact that so big part of school geometry concentrates on calculating areas and volumes, and not on properties of figures.)

So I wanted to brush up on circle theorems. I quickly read over the circle chapter on another geometry book I have, called "Geometry: A Guided Inquiry". (I can recommend that book as well. It often asks the student to explore and try find theorems. See more info here.)

I don't know about you, but to me, reading & learning theorems and proofs can be enjoyable. First you maybe struggle to grasp it all, but afterwards there is a great satisfying feeling and admiration of the logical process - and it's BEAUTIFUL.

So I thought I'd blog about inscribed angles... so you see a tiny glimpse of this logical process of proof.

1) Let's suppose we've already proved this theorem: that inscribed angles are equal, and are half of the corresponding central angle.



All these angles A are equal (or congruent as they say), and are half of angle B.

I can even draw many of them in the same pic: now the red, blue, black, and green angles have the same measure, exactly half of angle B.




(As a sideline, if we make B to be 180 degrees so it forms a diameter, then what is the measure of A?)

For proof of this theorem, see Inscribed and Central Angles in a Circle: What is this about? A Mathematical Droodle - a nice interactive applet shows the angle relationship, too.

2) THEN, after understanding that, let's consider two chords in a circle that intersect.




Filling in some more lines, we get what I'd call the "slanted timeglass figure".

We see there are two inscribed angles here, from the same points, and they're congruent (angles A and A').

Angles B and B' are congruent since they're vertical angles.

SO.... even the third angles of these two triangles must be equal (since angles in a triangle always add up to 180 degrees).

It follows that we have two SIMILAR TRIANGLES! We have just PROVEN that the time glass figure inside a circle consists of two similar (same shape) triangles.




Well that was just a tiny tiny glimpse, but I hope you see how this process could work. And I wish our students can get these tiny glimpses even BEFORE high school geometry - to learn appreciate math a little more, to see its beauty in action, to learn what proving is all about. In my mind, proofs are NOT something boring - they're part of the beauty of mathematics.


Tags: ,

Monday, May 22, 2006

Proving triangles congruent

My child is dealing identifying Triangles as SAS,SSS,AAS,ASA and HL Theroms. She is also having trouble with the Flow proofs and Column proofs on explaing why 2 triangles are congruent.


All of the theorems about proving that triangles (or other shapes) are congruent can be "translated" into a drawing problem:

If I have my 'secret' triangle and I give you THESE pieces of information, can you reproduce my triangle? Can you do that every time, no matter what my triangle?

We can describe a triangle using 6 pieces of information: the legths of the three sides, and the measures of the three angles. But you don't need all of those to be able to draw my secret triangle.

Can you draw a copy of my triangle if I tell you that....

  • my triangle has a side 5 cm long, another side 6 cm long, and the angle between those sides is 29 degrees (I've given you S - A - S)?

  • my triangle has a 30 degree angle, a 60 degree angle, and a 90 degree angle (I've given you A - A - A)?


In the first case, yes, and in the second case, no.

On proving problems, often the two triangles in the figure look obviously congruent and so it may be hard to see what there is to prove. But you simply need to look for corresponding side and angle parts in the two triangles that are known to be the same length or same angle measure.

Two angles in a figure might be the same if they're vertical angles or corresponding angles, or base angles of a isosceles triangle. (Or it is given.)

Two sides might be the same length if they are halves of a longer line (there is a midpoint). Or, they ARE the same line. Or you have a rectangle or square somewhere. (Or, it is given.)

For example, the image below does NOT depict two congruent triangles.

not congruent triangles

But this image does - because I made the point K to be a midpoint for the two intersecting line segments.

two congruent triangles

So there you have two pairs of lines of same length. And you have vertical angles which are the same - can you see how we then have S - A - S same in the two triangles -> they're congruent.

Maybe it would help to read explanations of this stuff a few times, from different places, with different wordings. It is not really difficult, I don't think!

Practice problems for congruent triangles from Yahoo education

Geometry: Congruent Triangles. Math for Morons like us.


Recognizing congruent triangles
- interactive practice page from Oswego City School District Regents Exam Prep Center


Proving Rriangles Congruent interactive gizmo
from ExploreLearning.com.
- you get 5 minutes free exploration time. It's a great site and great 'gizmos'.

What is proof - my own article.

Tags: , , , ,

Proving triangles congruent

My child is dealing identifying Triangles as SAS,SSS,AAS,ASA and HL Theroms. She is also having trouble with the Flow proofs and Column proofs on explaing why 2 triangles are congruent.


All of the theorems about proving that triangles (or other shapes) are congruent can be "translated" into a drawing problem:

If I have my 'secret' triangle and I give you THESE pieces of information, can you reproduce my triangle? Can you do that every time, no matter what my triangle?

We can describe a triangle using 6 pieces of information: the legths of the three sides, and the measures of the three angles. But you don't need all of those to be able to draw my secret triangle.

Can you draw a copy of my triangle if I tell you that....

  • my triangle has a side 5 cm long, another side 6 cm long, and the angle between those sides is 29 degrees (I've given you S - A - S)?

  • my triangle has a 30 degree angle, a 60 degree angle, and a 90 degree angle (I've given you A - A - A)?


In the first case, yes, and in the second case, no.

On proving problems, often the two triangles in the figure look obviously congruent and so it may be hard to see what there is to prove. But you simply need to look for corresponding side and angle parts in the two triangles that are known to be the same length or same angle measure.

Two angles in a figure might be the same if they're vertical angles or corresponding angles, or base angles of a isosceles triangle. (Or it is given.)

Two sides might be the same length if they are halves of a longer line (there is a midpoint). Or, they ARE the same line. Or you have a rectangle or square somewhere. (Or, it is given.)

For example, the image below does NOT depict two congruent triangles.

not congruent triangles

But this image does - because I made the point K to be a midpoint for the two intersecting line segments.

two congruent triangles

So there you have two pairs of lines of same length. And you have vertical angles which are the same - can you see how we then have S - A - S same in the two triangles -> they're congruent.

Maybe it would help to read explanations of this stuff a few times, from different places, with different wordings. It is not really difficult, I don't think!

Practice problems for congruent triangles from Yahoo education

Geometry: Congruent Triangles. Math for Morons like us.


Recognizing congruent triangles
- interactive practice page from Oswego City School District Regents Exam Prep Center


Proving Rriangles Congruent interactive gizmo
from ExploreLearning.com.
- you get 5 minutes free exploration time. It's a great site and great 'gizmos'.

What is proof - my own article.

Tags: , , , ,

Thursday, March 23, 2006

Prove that irrational*non-zero rational number is equal to an irrational number

How can you prove that irrational*non-zero rational number is equal to an irrational number?

I suspect this is a university student asking me this.

One important step in how to make proofs is to understand clearly what you're asked to prove. It often involves statements that are true for ALL numbers in a certain set (such as all real numbers, all rational numbers etc.).

This one does not include the word "all" nor the word "any", but it still is of that type. I can reword it like this:

Prove that any irrational number multiplied by any non-zero rational number is equal to some irrational number.


Or, this way:

Prove that for all irrational numbers x and for all rational numbers y excluding 0 the following is true: xy is an irrational number.


This question basically ASKS for indirect proof.

In indirect proof, we assume the OPPOSITE is true, and show that would lead to a contradiction.

We are supposed to prove that if you take ANY irrational number times ANY non-zero rational number, then the result is an irrational number.

So assume the opposite: assume there is SOME irrational number X and SOME non-zero rational number R so that when you multiply those two, you get a RATIONAL one as an answer:

XR = S and S is rational


Well, from this equation X = S/R (remember R is not zero so this is legal). But then X would be a rational number (S) divided by another rational number (R).

You probably already know that if you divide a rational number by a rational number, the result is going to be a rational number - never an irrational number, so this is the contradiction needed for the proof. ALL DONE!

But just for a reminder: a rational number is like fraction: a/b where a and b are integers, b nonzero. So if you take a/b ÷ c/d, you know how that is done: multiply by d/c and it produces another fraction (rational number).

Tags: , ,

Prove that irrational*non-zero rational number is equal to an irrational number

How can you prove that irrational*non-zero rational number is equal to an irrational number?

I suspect this is a university student asking me this.

One important step in how to make proofs is to understand clearly what you're asked to prove. It often involves statements that are true for ALL numbers in a certain set (such as all real numbers, all rational numbers etc.).

This one does not include the word "all" nor the word "any", but it still is of that type. I can reword it like this:

Prove that any irrational number multiplied by any non-zero rational number is equal to some irrational number.


Or, this way:

Prove that for all irrational numbers x and for all rational numbers y excluding 0 the following is true: xy is an irrational number.


This question basically ASKS for indirect proof.

In indirect proof, we assume the OPPOSITE is true, and show that would lead to a contradiction.

We are supposed to prove that if you take ANY irrational number times ANY non-zero rational number, then the result is an irrational number.

So assume the opposite: assume there is SOME irrational number X and SOME non-zero rational number R so that when you multiply those two, you get a RATIONAL one as an answer:

XR = S and S is rational


Well, from this equation X = S/R (remember R is not zero so this is legal). But then X would be a rational number (S) divided by another rational number (R).

You probably already know that if you divide a rational number by a rational number, the result is going to be a rational number - never an irrational number, so this is the contradiction needed for the proof. ALL DONE!

But just for a reminder: a rational number is like fraction: a/b where a and b are integers, b nonzero. So if you take a/b ÷ c/d, you know how that is done: multiply by d/c and it produces another fraction (rational number).

Tags: , ,

Friday, February 3, 2006

Proof before high school - remember to ask "Why?"

You might think, "Proof? You need it before high school geometry?"

Sure! But, we are talking about a different form of 'proving' here.

What IS proof, first of all? It is something that the person hearing or reading the 'proof' will become CONVINCED that whatever you're proving is, indeed, true.

You will want to convince your youngsters or students that what YOU ARE telling them, is indeed true. That is 'proving', in a general sense. But it doesn't have to be on the same level as later.

For example, when you are showing them how the multi-digit multiplication works and WHY it works (2 × 371 is the same as 2 × 300 + 2 × 70 + 2 × 1), you are proving - or maybe we should say "justifying".

When you take fraction manipulatives and demonstrate why 5 × 2/3 is 3 1/3, you are 'proving' - or demonstrating. (You take 5 times 2/3. You combine the thirds until you get 3 wholes and one third.)

Oftentimes diagrams or picturial illustrations work as 'proofs' in grade school. When students "see it", they become convinced. For example, using algebra tiles to show factorings in pre-algebra.

Those proofs are not as "rigorous" proofs that mathematicians do, but they are important, nonetheless. That way students get used to demonstrations as to WHY something works, and DON'T get used to "announced math" where rules are just given as step-by-step instructions without much explanations.

They can keep that small voice inside alive that says, "Why is that?"

Then, after you as the teacher have done it, change turns. It's time for YOU to ask WHY.
A good place for this is after the student has done some problems: ask why he/she did it this way.

"You added right. Now tell me WHY did you put that 2 up there above the other numbers?"

And, of course you will take special notice of the problems asking the student to justify his/her reasoning.

It doesn't have to be anymore complicated than that. Just don't forget it amidst all the drill and "you need to complete the worksheet" stuff. Take time to reflect, sometimes, and consider the "why".

See also the previous posts: What is proof? and Two-column proof versus paragraph proof.

Tags: ,

Proof before high school - remember to ask "Why?"

You might think, "Proof? You need it before high school geometry?"

Sure! But, we are talking about a different form of 'proving' here.

What IS proof, first of all? It is something that the person hearing or reading the 'proof' will become CONVINCED that whatever you're proving is, indeed, true.

You will want to convince your youngsters or students that what YOU ARE telling them, is indeed true. That is 'proving', in a general sense. But it doesn't have to be on the same level as later.

For example, when you are showing them how the multi-digit multiplication works and WHY it works (2 × 371 is the same as 2 × 300 + 2 × 70 + 2 × 1), you are proving - or maybe we should say "justifying".

When you take fraction manipulatives and demonstrate why 5 × 2/3 is 3 1/3, you are 'proving' - or demonstrating. (You take 5 times 2/3. You combine the thirds until you get 3 wholes and one third.)

Oftentimes diagrams or picturial illustrations work as 'proofs' in grade school. When students "see it", they become convinced. For example, using algebra tiles to show factorings in pre-algebra.

Those proofs are not as "rigorous" proofs that mathematicians do, but they are important, nonetheless. That way students get used to demonstrations as to WHY something works, and DON'T get used to "announced math" where rules are just given as step-by-step instructions without much explanations.

They can keep that small voice inside alive that says, "Why is that?"

Then, after you as the teacher have done it, change turns. It's time for YOU to ask WHY.
A good place for this is after the student has done some problems: ask why he/she did it this way.

"You added right. Now tell me WHY did you put that 2 up there above the other numbers?"

And, of course you will take special notice of the problems asking the student to justify his/her reasoning.

It doesn't have to be anymore complicated than that. Just don't forget it amidst all the drill and "you need to complete the worksheet" stuff. Take time to reflect, sometimes, and consider the "why".

See also the previous posts: What is proof? and Two-column proof versus paragraph proof.

Tags: ,